yardbarker
RealGM Basketball

Murray State Racers ArticlesMurray State Racers Articles

Early Season Tournaments: Brackets, Observations, And Odds: Part 1

While my preseason projections won’t be available until the end of October, I have cranked out the odds for the holiday tournaments based on my rankings. Today’s column looks at who is likely to win each early season tournament, and what storylines to keep an eye on.

Do not hesitate to print out the tournament brackets and follow along as they happen. It is extremely easy to get busy with the Thanksgiving holidays and miss some of the best games of the season. But if you print out these brackets and fill them in, you won’t miss the upsets. Just click on the handy links throughout this document to find the printable brackets.

Preseason NIT Printable Bracket

Nov 12-13, 21-23

 

Virginia

9.6%

Fairfield

0.3%

Delaware

1.2%

Pennsylvania

0.0%

Kansas St.

28.8%

Lamar

0.0%

North Texas

4.4%

Ala.-Huntsville

0.0%

Michigan

19.7%

IUPUI

0.0%

Cleveland St.

0.7%

Bowling Green

0.1%

Pittsburgh

28.6%

Fordham

0.0%

Lehigh

2.0%

Robert Morris

4.6%

I’ve already expressed my doubts about Michigan and my faith in Pittsburgh. But Pitt’s second round opponent will be very dangerous. Both Lehigh (led by NCAA hero CJ McCollum) and Robert Morris (led by super-scorer Velton Jones) have the ability to knock off Pittsburgh. These teams have a real chance to win the Patriot League and Northeast Conference, and this is the type of game that can mean the difference between earning a 15 seed and a 13 seed come March.

2K Sports Classic Printable Bracket

Nov 15-16

 

Oregon St.

12.0%

Alabama

48.2%

Purdue

16.5%

Villanova

23.4%

OSU’s Jared Cunningham, Alabama’s JaMychal Green, Purdue’s Robbie Hummel, and Villanova’s Maalik Wayns are gone, and those players were not only their team’s leading scorers last season, they were the heart of their respective offenses. Which rebuilding team will forge a new identity first? Because Anthony Grant has become a dominant defensive coach, while Craig Robinson has not, Alabama is the favorite here.

Charleston Classic Printable Bracket

Nov 15-18

 

Colorado

10.9%

Dayton

5.4%

Boston College

0.6%

Baylor

42.5%

Charleston

7.2%

St. John's

8.5%

Auburn

4.4%

Murray St.

20.5%

There are some big name conference schools here, but this tournament is a dream for fans of mid-major squads. Murray St. won’t be able to duplicate last year’s 31-2 record, but with superstar point-guard Isaiah Canaan returning, Murray St. should have enough to beat Auburn and St. John’s. In fact, they might even face the College of Charleston in the semifinals. This offseason Charleston added head coach Doug Wojcik, a veteran coach who hasn’t been able to get to the NCAA tournament, but a coach who has consistently built strong defensive teams. If Wojcik can get Charleston to play great defense this season, he has enough returning talent to make a run at an NCAA tournament bid. Andrew Lawrence is clearly Charleston’s best returning offensive player, but the real player to keep an eye on is Adjehi Baru. Baru was ranked 37th in the nation out of high school and is one of the highest ranked recruits to ever attend Charleston. And while Baru was a nice complimentary player as a freshman last season, it will be very interesting to see if he can break out as a sophomore.

Of course the clear favorite here is Baylor. Baylor may have lost some key post players to graduation and the NBA, but they have plenty of incoming talent. This will be our first chance to see the highly acclaimed 7’1” freshman Isaiah Austin in action.

Puerto Rico Tipoff Printable Bracket

Nov 15-18

 

Oklahoma St.

13.3%

Akron

6.1%

Tennessee

33.5%

NC Asheville

0.1%

Penn St.

3.2%

NC State

36.4%

Massachusetts

5.7%

Providence

1.7% 

Oklahoma St.’s odds aren’t poor because Oklahoma St. is a bad team. The Cowboys add Top 10 freshman Marcus Smart alongside former Top 10 recruit LeBryan Nash. That one-two punch will make Oklahoma St. a likely NCAA tournament team this year. But the Cowboys have a terrible tournament draw.  First Oklahoma St. has to face Akron. Akron point guard Alex Abreu may be under-sized, but he’s an extremely talented player, and 7 foot center Zeke Marshall could have played for a number of BCS teams. And while the MAC hasn’t had multiple NCAA bids since 1999, Ohio and Akron are strong enough to break that trend.

Meanwhile Tennessee is a heavy favorite to be the second round opponent. Tennessee may have only finished 19-15 last year, but the Vols played substantially better after Jarnell Stokes joined the team mid-season. And with Trae Golden and Jeronne Maymon becoming efficient scorers for head coach Cuonzo Martin, a lot of people have taken notice. Florida head coach Billy Donovan has gone on the record to say that Tennessee is the team to beat in the SEC this season.

And if Oklahoma St. wins that game, they only have to face NC State in the final, the same NC State team that many people have labeled as the ACC favorite. So no, Oklahoma St. isn’t a bad team. But their path to a Puerto Rico tipoff title is brutal.

Coaches vs Cancer

Nov 16-17

 

BYU

13.2%

Florida St.

29.4%

Notre Dame

32.3%

St. Joseph's

25.1% 

If you get tired of the sloppy play by all the new players in November, please don’t miss Notre Dame vs St. Joseph’s in the first round of the Coaches vs Cancer tournament. Both teams return all five starters from last season and have plenty of offensive stars. I’m going to keep writing about the shot-blocking CJ Aiken, super-slasher Carl Jones, and the super-efficient Langston Galloway until St. Joe’s gets more love, but this four team field is wide open.

Notre Dame is the favorite, but I do have one question for Irish fans. Given Scott Martin’s middling efficiency numbers in his career, was it a good thing that the NCAA granted him an additional year of eligibility? Martin made just 26% of his threes and 40% of his twos last year, and while injuries may have contributed to that, it is clear he wasn’t an elite player last year.

Paradise Jam Printable Bracket

Nov 16-19

 

George Mason

3.0%

Mercer

6.2%

New Mexico

69.0%

Illinois Chicago

0.1%

Connecticut

10.6%

Wake Forest

2.1%

Iona

6.0%

Quinnipiac

3.1%

Despite a host of mid-major schools, this tournament looks very dull. Mercer and Iona might compete for the ASun and MAAC titles this year, but neither looks like a likely at-large bid.

And still Connecticut’s tournament odds are not great. First NCAA tournament sanctions led to a host of transfers this off-season. Then the Huskies lost Jim Calhoun to retirement. And as we’ve seen in recent seasons, UConn has been a different team when Calhoun is out. He’s a special coach who can elevate the level of his players, and he will not easily be replaced.

Steve Alford’s team might actually be a little better on offense this season. The team loses Drew Gordon at the forward position, but New Mexico also loses AJ Hardeman. And as great an offensive player as Gordon was, Hardeman was a black hole on offense. With Alex Kirk returning from injury to provide that shot-blocking presence in the paint, and all the returning talent at the guard spots, New Mexico deserves more preseason praise.

Hall of Fame Tip-Off Printable Bracket

Nov 17-18

 

Rhode Island

0.3%

Ohio St.

76.9%

Washington

11.7%

Seton Hall

11.1%

Washington’s Abdul Gaddy has had an injury filled career, but with Tony Wroten leaving early for the draft, this is Gaddy’s team. The senior point-guard will have to integrate some new pieces throughout the Washington lineup. Seton Hall will have a number of new faces as well, including Georgia Tech transfer Brian Oliver and Southern Illinois transfer Gene Teague. Realistically, the winner of this game will probably be headed to the NIT, but a win against Ohio St. would be a fantastic notch on any NCAA resume. While Ohio St. is the clear favorite thanks to the efficient high volume shooter DeShaun Thomas, there are questions about how the Buckeyes offense will run without Jared Sullinger.

Beating The Top Teams

This first table recreates the Pomeroy rankings using only games against NCAA tournament teams:

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

1

Michigan St.

117.6

84.8

12

5

0.9662

2

Missouri

127.7

93.4

11

3

0.9611

3

Kentucky

122.9

89.9

11

2

0.9609

4

Ohio St.

117.8

86.4

10

6

0.9599

5

Kansas

114.6

86.7

12

6

0.9459

6

Murray St.

117.9

90.2

4

0

0.9397

7

North Carolina

116.9

90.1

12

5

0.9355

8

Indiana

121.2

93.8

8

5

0.9322

9

Georgetown

115.1

89.1

8

6

0.9322

10

VCU

116.7

90.5

3

1

0.9312

11

Vanderbilt

117.2

91.4

6

5

0.9274

12

Wisconsin

112.0

87.6

7

7

0.9250

13

Syracuse

113.9

89.3

12

2

0.9242

14

Wichita St.

117.9

92.5

4

3

0.9229

15

Florida

121.7

96.0

5

6

0.9187

16

Michigan

114.8

91.3

7

7

0.9129

17

Florida St.

109.9

87.6

7

5

0.9114

18

Southern Miss

116.8

93.3

5

2

0.9090

19

Duke

119.3

95.4

10

5

0.9082

20

St. Louis

115.1

92.2

4

3

0.9074

- No one has performed better against NCAA tournament teams than Michigan St. While their winning percentage isn’t the best, when accounting for opponent, venue, and margin-of-victory, the Spartans have been the most dominant.

- While Syracuse has an impressive 12-2 record against tournament teams, the reality is that they haven’t been completely dominant in those games. They’ve escaped with close wins against Georgetown, Connecticut, West Virginia, and others.

- I’m not sure I would trust these numbers for teams with very few games. Sure VCU has great numbers, but they played Western Kentucky twice and crushed them, and they beat South Florida handily while the Bulls were missing multiple starters. Similarly, Murray St.’s impressive stats are driven by one blowout win over St. Mary’s.

- But for teams with numerous games against tournament teams, the stats are more revealing. Duke has played 15 games against NCAA teams and while they’ve gone 10-5, they haven’t exactly been blowing teams out.

- Ken Pomeroy has rightfully argued that Southern Miss is over-seeded. But the reason that happened is because the Golden Eagles have been at their best against quality competition.

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

21

Louisville

106.2

85.1

11

8

0.9068

22

New Mexico

112.3

90.0

7

4

0.9059

23

Temple

118.0

95.0

5

2

0.9023

24

Colorado

103.4

83.5

2

3

0.8991

25

Marquette

111.9

90.5

9

6

0.8988

26

Kansas St.

111.6

90.3

6

8

0.8979

27

Baylor

119.4

96.7

10

7

0.8967

28

Gonzaga

110.8

90.2

5

4

0.8923

29

Cincinnati

111.8

93.1

7

6

0.8676

30

Alabama

106.4

88.6

4

6

0.8667

31

UNLV

112.3

93.7

5

6

0.8654

32

St. Mary's

118.6

98.9

4

3

0.8654

33

Ohio

110.8

92.5

2

1

0.8643

34

Texas

113.8

95.0

4

11

0.8640

35

Xavier

110.7

92.5

5

7

0.8625

36

Iowa St.

110.6

93.4

7

7

0.8497

37

Lehigh

123.6

104.8

0

2

0.8450

38

Virginia

104.6

88.7

2

6

0.8436

39

Belmont

113.3

96.4

0

2

0.8391

40

Creighton

121.0

103.2

3

1

0.8353

- No one has played more games against tournament teams than Louisville. And while the Cardinal haven’t always been dominant, they have been tested.

- Baylor may be a No. 3 seed, but they’ve struggled against NCAA tournament teams.

- Texas has been close in a lot of games, but the 4-11 record indicates that they’ve rarely earned the win against quality competition.

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

41

Connecticut

111.3

95.1

7

8

0.8337

42

Davidson

116.0

99.8

1

3

0.8241

43

Purdue

117.6

101.4

3

10

0.8195

44

West Virginia

111.4

96.3

4

8

0.8160

45

San Diego St.

108.6

94.1

6

6

0.8130

46

Notre Dame

105.8

91.9

10

7

0.8086

47

Harvard

93.7

81.6

2

1

0.8047

48

Memphis

112.5

98.4

3

6

0.7981

49

Long Beach St.

112.1

98.2

1

7

0.7953

50

NC State

111.2

98.1

4

9

0.7838

51

Iona

112.6

100.6

3

2

0.7604

52

Montana

105.0

95.6

1

1

0.7252

53

St. Bonaventure

109.5

101.4

2

4

0.6878

54

New Mexico St.

100.6

93.3

1

3

0.6856

55

Detroit

93.8

87.8

0

2

0.6635

56

Loyola (MD)

104.9

99.3

1

3

0.6363

57

Norfolk St.

94.3

89.7

1

2

0.6252

58

Colorado St.

107.4

102.6

5

6

0.6136

59

BYU

104.1

100.1

1

6

0.5991

60

South Florida

92.4

91.6

3

10

0.5215

61

Vermont

101.2

100.5

0

5

0.5166

62

Lamar

95.5

94.9

0

4

0.5163

63

NC Asheville

102.0

102.2

0

4

0.4952

64

Long Island

101.5

103.7

1

2

0.4443

65

California

97.0

99.3

1

5

0.4412

66

Western Kentucky

97.5

102.2

0

4

0.3794

67

Mississippi Valley St.

91.5

96.5

0

5

0.3658

68

South Dakota St.

   

0

0

 

- South Florida hasn’t performed well against tournament teams, but play-in game opponent California has been even worse.

- Memphis has also earned its keep by crushing non-tournament teams. Against the tournament field they have been merely average.

- Amazingly, South Dakota St. did not play a single NCAA tournament team during the regular season.

Last 10 Games Splits

But how have these teams done in the last 10 games?

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

1

Michigan St.

121.5

84.4

8

2

0.9767

2

Memphis

119.6

83.4

9

1

0.9757

3

Kentucky

123.2

89.1

9

1

0.9652

4

North Carolina

120.5

87.8

9

1

0.9623

5

Wichita St.

121.7

90.5

9

1

0.9542

6

Kansas

120.0

90.0

9

1

0.9505

7

Missouri

132.5

99.3

8

2

0.9504

8

Vanderbilt

119.8

90.0

7

3

0.9494

9

Ohio St.

119.1

90.4

6

4

0.9441

10

Indiana

122.5

93.2

8

2

0.9427

11

Syracuse

117.7

90.9

9

1

0.9336

12

Purdue

129.8

102.3

6

4

0.9201

13

Georgetown

111.7

88.2

6

4

0.9180

14

Baylor

120.1

94.9

6

4

0.9179

15

Wisconsin

115.7

92.1

6

4

0.9116

16

Belmont

117.8

94.3

10

0

0.9072

17

New Mexico

110.8

89.2

8

2

0.9021

18

South Florida

97.4

78.9

7

3

0.8965

19

St. Louis

108.1

87.7

8

2

0.8945

20

Kansas St.

111.2

90.5

6

4

0.8922

- Now Memphis becomes an even bigger dilemma. They’ve been playing like one of the top teams in the country lately, but when they played tournament teams, they weren’t nearly as good. Which team will show up on Friday?

- Belmont is currently clicking on all cylinders which makes them a trendy pick to upset Georgetown.

- And don’t sleep on South Florida. They were a much better team at the end of the season, even if they can’t score to save their life.

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

21

Florida St.

111.8

91.2

8

2

0.8899

22

Marquette

114.1

93.1

7

3

0.8897

23

Michigan

115.7

94.5

7

3

0.8891

24

Duke

114.0

93.2

8

2

0.8878

25

Louisville

100.1

81.9

6

4

0.8873

26

Cincinnati

113.8

93.4

7

3

0.8836

27

Iowa St.

113.9

93.5

6

4

0.8834

28

St. Bonaventure

118.9

98.3

8

2

0.8753

29

Gonzaga

112.9

94.1

8

2

0.8658

30

Florida

121.1

101.9

4

6

0.8546

31

Long Beach St.

108.1

91.2

8

2

0.8507

32

New Mexico St.

110.9

93.7

8

2

0.8479

33

NC State

111.9

94.8

5

5

0.8458

34

Connecticut

112.6

96.0

5

5

0.8357

35

California

109.1

93.2

7

3

0.8342

36

Virginia

102.5

87.6

4

6

0.8332

37

Notre Dame

111.4

95.3

7

3

0.8316

38

Temple

115.8

99.1

8

2

0.8316

39

Alabama

103.6

89.0

6

4

0.8270

40

Colorado St.

113.1

97.3

6

4

0.8244

- Louisville really is the perfect analogy to last year’s UConn team. They limped to the finish in the regular season before winning the Big East tournament. Overall in the last 10, they haven’t been that great, but over the last 4 games they were special.

- Duke was simply not dominant over the teams last 10 games.

 

Team

Adj Off

Adj Def

W

L

Pythag.

41

Texas

113.9

98.5

6

4

0.8168

42

South Dakota St.

112.6

97.5

9

1

0.8129

43

San Diego St.

108.6

94.9

6

4

0.8004

44

VCU

107.0

94.1

9

1

0.7883

45

Ohio

109.1

96.3

8

2

0.7839

46

Montana

103.0

91.5

10

0

0.7702

47

Davidson

109.8

97.6

8

2

0.7696

48

Creighton

118.8

105.7

7

3

0.7675

49

Murray St.

105.9

94.4

9

1

0.7646

50

Xavier

108.1

96.6

6

4

0.7600

51

Harvard

108.1

97.1

8

2

0.7514

52

UNLV

104.2

93.7

5

5

0.7483

53

West Virginia

111.0

99.9

4

6

0.7471

54

Colorado

101.6

91.9

7

3

0.7355

55

Iona

121.1

109.6

8

2

0.7347

56

Lehigh

105.4

95.5

9

1

0.7328

57

St. Mary's

113.1

102.5

7

3

0.7321

58

Detroit

109.7

99.6

9

1

0.7287

59

Vermont

101.2

91.9

9

1

0.7277

60

BYU

101.5

92.7

7

3

0.7171

61

NC Asheville

106.2

98.1

8

2

0.6934

62

Lamar

105.6

98.9

7

3

0.6617

63

Southern Miss

107.3

104.2

5

5

0.5731

64

Western Kentucky

101.6

98.9

7

3

0.5693

65

Loyola (MD)

104.1

102.9

7

3

0.5281

66

Long Island

111.6

110.6

9

1

0.5236

67

Norfolk St.

97.9

103.6

9

1

0.3572

68

Mississippi Valley St.

93.8

108.3

9

1

0.1869

- As much as I love Texas based on all their close losses to quality teams, they sort of limped to the finish. They may have defeated Iowa St. in the Big 12 tournament, but before that they were struggling to beat teams like Texas Tech.

- Murray St. also struggled down the stretch in the OVC. They were winning games, but not by a margin that would suggest a deep NCAA tournament run.

Initial Bracket Thoughts

Because of the fast pace of both teams, BYU versus Iona has the potential to be one of the most entertaining First Four games of all-time. Also, I am salivating at seeing Missouri’s guards and Florida’s guards potentially clashing in the round of 32. But before I start breaking down the bracket, let’s throw a few quick stats at the wall:

Which Conferences Did the Best?

One thing I like to track during the NCAA tournament is whether conferences are exceeding expectations or falling short. One way to do that is to look at how seeds have performed from 1985 to 2011 and predict an expected number of wins for each conference.

(Note: In all tables I am only counting wins in the Round of 64 and beyond.)

Seed

Expected Wins

1

3.37

2

2.43

3

1.86

4

1.47

5

1.19

6

1.19

7

0.82

8

0.69

9

0.58

10

0.65

11

0.54

12

0.52

13

0.25

14

0.17

15

0.04

16

0.00

Based on these seed expectations and the seeds received, the Big East should win the most games in the tournament, but the Big Ten is expected to win nearly as many games with three fewer teams.

Conference

Teams

EW

Big East

9

12.06

Big Ten

6

10.86

ACC

5

8.85

Big 12

6

8.64

SEC

4

5.96

MWC

4

4.11

A10

4

2.59

MVC

2

1.88

WCC

3

1.73

CUSA

2

1.27

Pac12

2

0.80

MAAC

2

0.13

Other

19

4.21

We can also use this year’s margin-of-victory numbers to form an expectation. In the next table I use Ken Pomeroy’s predicted probabilities. Here we get a slightly different picture. His model expects the Big Ten to win the most games in the tournament, with the ACC earning far fewer wins than their high seeds would indicate:

Conference

Teams

Pomeroy

Big Ten

6

12.03

Big 12

6

9.70

Big East

9

9.36

ACC

5

6.99

SEC

4

6.34

MWC

4

3.63

A10

4

2.67

MVC

2

2.30

WCC

3

1.56

CUSA

2

1.44

Pac12

2

1.13

MAAC

2

0.29

Other

19

5.55

Team-By-Team

2012 is the year of the clear favorite. It will be virtually impossible for any of the experts who follow college basketball not to pick Kentucky to win the national championship. In terms of the measured statistics like margin-of-victory, in terms of the NBA ready talent on the floor, in terms of 34 games on TV over four months, no one has come close to the Wildcats this season.

But more importantly, there are no clear alternatives to the Wildcats. Again using Ken Pomeroy’s formula, here are the expected wins for each team in the tournament this year:

Team

Seed

EW

Kentucky

1

3.38

Ohio St.

2

3.38

Michigan St.

1

2.80

Kansas

2

2.74

North Carolina

1

2.56

Missouri

2

2.47

Syracuse

1

2.25

Wisconsin

4

2.09

Duke

2

1.75

Rather than showing one clear alternative, the numbers show a great deal of balance between the top seeds.

The Right Side of the Bracket (East and Midwest)

The margin-of-victory crowd is going to love Ohio St., but they might be the only ones. Despite bringing back one of the top post players in the country in Jared Sullinger, one of the top defenders in Aaron Craft, one of the most prolific two-guards in William Buford, and watching Deshaun Thomas emerge into a versatile scoring threat, Ohio St.’s offense has struggled at times this year. Ohio St. has simply not been able to replace the outside shooting of Jon Diebler. And by sharing the Big Ten title and falling to Michigan St. in the conference tournament, very few people are going to be in love with this team. Add in a potential Sweet Sixteen match-up with a Florida St. team that has two wins against Duke and two wins against North Carolina, and Ohio St. will get far less love than these numbers would suggest.

Syracuse is the more traditional favorite, but they are the worst defensive rebounding team in the field, and their offense can look stagnant when they aren’t forcing turnovers. Even a second round match-up against Kansas St. could be a nightmare for Syracuse. Kansas St.’s team is built to crash the glass, and if Angel Rodriguez can simply throw up jump shots (instead of turning the ball over at his normally high rate), Kansas St. might have a chance for an upset.

North Carolina is the choice for people who like NBA talent, but the ACC was so weak this year, the Tar Heels didn’t get their normal share of big games. And when they did play quality teams, they would usually be close. UNC would win 54-51 against Virginia or 69-67 against NC State. Certainly everyone says North Carolina has a lot of NBA ready talent on paper, but unlike Kentucky, it never felt like North Carolina was unbeatable. Ever since the big win over Michigan St. on an aircraft carrier to start the season, they rarely gave off that aura of invincibility. And with John Henson’s injury this weekend, there are additional doubts about the Tar Heels.

If you are scared away by Kentucky’s inexperience, you might like Kansas. The Jayhawks don’t have any amazing freshmen this year because the majority of their recruiting class was declared academically ineligible to start the season. That has left Kansas with a veteran lineup and Bill Self has clearly got the most out of every player on the floor. The once ridiculed Tyshawn Taylor has emerged as a polished superstar and Thomas Robinson emerged into quite possibly the best player in the country.

But when you look at this group of four teams (Syracuse, Ohio St., North Carolina, and Kansas) any honest evaluation would say that it truly is a toss-up. I would unquestionably pick these four teams for the regional finals on that half of the bracket, but I have no idea which of these teams will play in the national title game.

The Left Side of the Bracket (West)

On the other side of the bracket, it is hard not to love what Michigan St. has accomplished this year. But the Spartans got the worst possible second round draw. Memphis has been absolutely demolishing teams lately, winning their last seven games by 18 points or more. Michigan St. may be able to exploit Memphis’ lack of size in the paint better than any team in the nation, but they shouldn’t have to face such a dominant team in the second round. (Oh, and if St. Louis upsets Memphis, they have elite margin-of-victory numbers too.) So even if Michigan St. was a reasonable pick for a deep run based on their performance in the toughest conference in the country this year, the bracket makes the Spartans a very risky bet.

Instead many people will be drawn to the sentimental favorite Missouri. Don’t pick against the Tigers because of their lack of depth. They’ve played smart and avoided foul trouble all year. Don’t pick against the Tigers because of their lack of size. They’ve played bigger teams all year, and they’ve actually struggled more against smaller quicker teams. In fact, I would argue that picking against Missouri is the most unpleasant thing you could possibly do this year. With only 7 scholarship players, this group has developed a type of offensive chemistry that will help you rediscover a love for basketball.

I think part of what made the Missouri offense so good this year was the change of pace. Normally when a player goes to the NBA they realize that the game is much faster. But eventually the game slows down. Well, Missouri is having a slow-down moment. While Missouri still plays at an exceedingly fast-pace relative to most teams, it is much slower than what they played under Mike Anderson. Somehow the game is very calm and controlled for them, while remaining at a fever pitch for opponents.

Ricardo Ratliffe is the perfect example. Teams know that he shoots nearly 70% in the paint so they cannot afford to let him get paint touches, but somehow the Missouri guards are always cutting and using screens and finding a way to get him the ball in scoring position. And Ratliffe probably has the quickest release of any post player in college today. He rarely holds the ball and lets the defense react. He catches the ball and gets it up on the backboard immediately

Having said all that, I’m not in love with Missouri’s draw. Let me get to that:

First, I really like Florida over Virginia. A number of the experts say that Virginia likes to play a pack-line defense and force teams to shoot over the top. Well, Florida is not afraid to shoot over the top. But I actually think that is a little over-rated. Virginia has played the pack-line defense, but still been quick enough to get out on shooters. What concerns me more than anything is how poorly Virginia has played since Assane Sene has gone down. The defense just hasn’t been the same without the 7 footer in the middle, and he is not going to be back for the tournament.

And if Florida advances to face Missouri, that’s a dream match-up on paper. While Missouri has succeeded by playing four guards around Ricardo Ratliffe, that will allow Florida to play four guards around Patric Young. And while Kentucky has almost single-handedly convinced the country that Florida isn’t very good, realistically Florida is almost the mirror-image of Missouri. Missouri might be the favorite, but that game would be very close to a toss-up.

And if Missouri faces Marquette in the Sweet Sixteen, Marquette is another team that has the quickness to stay with Missouri. Plus Buzz Williams clearly takes his scouting to another level in the NCAA tournament. Facing his team after a four day break would be a nightmare.

The Left Side of the Bracket (South)

Duke drew the short straw getting placed in the same region as Kentucky. And the Blue Devils were also clearly the least dominant of the 1 and 2 seeds during the regular season. Give Mike Krzyzewski credit for putting together the right non-conference schedule that got Duke the quality wins they need to be a 2-seed, but even the usually Duke-loving Dick Vitale has said that this is not a vintage Duke team. When Vitale says the Blue Devils might lose in the second round of the tournament, you know they have flaws. Now is probably a good time for me to show another Expected Win chart:

Team

Seed

EW

Baylor

3

1.73

Wichita St.

5

1.61

Marquette

3

1.51

Indiana

4

1.48

Georgetown

3

1.36

New Mexico

5

1.34

Michigan

4

1.33

Louisville

4

1.24

Florida St.

3

1.19

Vanderbilt

5

1.17

Baylor will be the clear pick to upset Duke for some people based on the large amount of NBA talent on their roster. But as an NBA-centered team, they remind me a lot of recent Texas teams under Rick Barnes. Somehow showing off their game for NBA scouts is more important than winning. Baylor proved some skeptics wrong by beating Kansas in the Big 12 tournament, but if Missouri will make you love college basketball, cheering for Baylor will absolutely drive you nuts. You almost have to beg for Perry Jones III to get a post touch, and while Brady Heslip is a great sharp-shooter, he doesn’t seem to have any feel for when to take threes and when to work the offense.

Dark Horses

- I’ve already written at length about how Wisconsin’s numbers are inflated based on crushing a bunch of small teams early in the season. But I do believe the Badgers are dangerous. My main concern with picking them is that at their slow pace, they open up the door to losing any game. Montana is clearly not in Wisconsin’s league, but in a 58 possession game, against a solid Montana defense, the game will probably be close.

- Wichita St. is the most dominant MVC team since Ken Pomeroy began tracking stats, and they have the kind of 7-foot center in Garrett Stutz that a lot of mid-major teams do not. That is why Seth Davis was professing his love for this team on CBS.

- Vanderbilt absolutely has the talent at every position to beat any team in the country. And they should long savor their win over Kentucky in the SEC final. But the main complaint is that the Commodores have failed to play well against weaker teams. With basically the same lineup they’ve lost in the first round of the NCAA tournament in previous years, and they had many games this season where they struggled with weaker opponents. Sure, I’ll believe you if you say they can beat Syracuse. But can they even get to that game?

- Finally, Florida St. is the team that a lot of people are going to be picking based on the ACC tournament title. But again, they have a potential nightmare match-up if they face Cincinnati. The Bearcats are one of the best teams in the country at forcing steals and Florida St.’s biggest weakness is holding on to the ball. Sure, they might be able to beat Ohio St. But can they even get to that game?

Here are more expected wins in the round of 64 and beyond:

Team

Seed

EW

Kansas St.

8

1.14

UNLV

6

1.11

Memphis

8

1.09

Florida

7

0.95

Purdue

10

0.94

Murray St.

6

0.92

Notre Dame

7

0.90

Texas

11

0.90

Temple

5

0.84

Alabama

9

0.84

Belmont

14

0.81

Cincinnati

6

0.79

NC State

11

0.78

Gonzaga

7

0.75

Iowa St.

8

0.71

Virginia

10

0.71

Creighton

8

0.69

Xavier

10

0.67

California

12

0.67

St. Louis

9

0.66

San Diego St.

6

0.64

Connecticut

9

0.56

West Virginia

10

0.55

Colorado St.

11

0.54

St. Mary's

7

0.53

Long Beach St.

12

0.52

St. Bonaventure

14

0.50

Colorado

11

0.46

Harvard

12

0.46

South Dakota St.

14

0.44

Ohio

13

0.44

Davidson

13

0.39

Southern Miss

9

0.35

- In case it wasn’t clear how terrible the draw is for Memphis and St. Louis. Memphis has the 9th best Pomeroy ranking, but is 22nd in expected wins. St. Louis had the 15th best Pomeroy ranking, but is 39th in expected wins.

- Southern Miss has some of the worst margin-of-victory stats in the field. Don’t pick them to upset Kansas St.

And here is the last of the list:

Team

Seed

EW

Lehigh

15

0.34

VCU

12

0.32

New Mexico St.

13

0.29

BYU

14

0.28

Iona

14

0.23

South Florida

12

0.21

Montana

13

0.17

NC Asheville

16

0.12

Detroit

15

0.11

Lamar

16

0.09

Loyola MD

15

0.06

Vermont

16

0.05

Norfolk St.

15

0.04

Long Island

16

0.04

Western Kentucky

16

0.02

Miss. Valley St.

16

0.00

Parting Thoughts

- Seth Davis said it well at the end of the selection special, the NCAA committee sent a message that non-conference strength-of-schedule matters. That’s why Iona got in ahead of Drexel. And that’s why Missouri was not a #1 seed. A lot of people will argue with that message. What does non-conference strength-of-schedule have to do with evaluating the quality of a team? Isn’t the goal to pick the best teams? But I’ve been watching this show for 20 years, and the committee has always had this emphasis. They want to incentivize teams to play big games early in the season, and whether it is an explicit criteria or not, it is a criteria.

- I still can’t believe Kevin Harlan weaved in a comment about Peyton Manning during the Arizona vs Colorado Pac-12 final. (Yes, Manning probably won’t be choosing between Denver and Arizona based on the outcome of that game.)

- Finally, only Bob Knight could manage to eat an ice cream cone while calling a college basketball game.

The Many Facets & Unpredictability Of March Madness

While personnel determine scheme in the NBA, college basketball coaches recruit players that fit their schemes.

Looking Back, Looking Ahead To Tournament Week

Examining the final regular season weekend of the Big Ten, ACC and SEC, along with everything you really need to know to enjoy Tournament Week.

YABC Column For Feb. 27th (POY Races, Improbabilities & More)

As Draymond Green locked up the Big Ten POY award and Kansas battled Missouri for a likely No. 1 seed, Saturday afternoon encapsulated everything that is great about the NCAA regular season.

YACB Column, Jan. 30th (On The Weaknesses Of The Top-25 & More)

Many have called this a down year for college basketball and though that argument can be made about elite teams, there are still plenty of reasons why it's a fallacy.

YACB Column, Dec. 12: (On Indiana's Upset Of UK, Xavier/Cincinnati Brawl & More)

On why Indiana was going in the right direction before their upset of Kentucky, how the Xavier/Cincinnati brawl could have been prevented, Draymond Green, USC, Notre Dame and more.
 

Basketball Wiretap Headlines

    NBA Wiretap Headlines

      NCAA Wiretap Headlines

        MLB Wiretap Headlines

          NFL Wiretap Headlines

            NHL Wiretap Headlines