May 12, 2013 10:35 PM EDT 
Andrew Wiggins is expected to make his college decision on Tuesday afternoon. Assuming the announcement is not leaked on Monday, I plan to post an updated Top 25 around 7pm ET on Tuesday evening. Even if Wiggins commits to Kentucky, the numbers below will not change substantially. The Wildcats are already projected as the No. 1 team in the nation and Kentucky is deep enough that another elite recruit won’t dramatically change the team’s outlook.
But this week I wanted to focus on the SEC because two other key decisions have already happened. First, Florida added Rutgers transfer Eli Carter. Second, it was announced that Tennessee guard Trae Golden will not return next year. With that news, here is how my lineup-based model projects the SEC standings to shake out next year:
|
Team
|
Proj CW
|
Proj CL
|
Proj Off
|
Proj Def
|
Last Off
|
Last Def
|
T100
|
Ret Min
|
Ret Poss
|
|
Kentucky
|
15
|
3
|
123.6
|
92.5
|
110.3
|
95.4
|
9
|
44%
|
42%
|
|
Florida
|
15
|
3
|
115.7
|
87.2
|
117.2
|
83.5
|
7
|
54%
|
51%
|
|
Alabama
|
11
|
7
|
106.0
|
89.2
|
102.5
|
89.7
|
6
|
70%
|
72%
|
|
Tennessee
|
11
|
7
|
109.2
|
93.5
|
108.3
|
97.7
|
4
|
60%
|
64%
|
|
LSU
|
10
|
8
|
110.9
|
96.4
|
104.7
|
97.9
|
4
|
75%
|
76%
|
|
Vanderbilt
|
10
|
8
|
105.5
|
92.2
|
101.8
|
93.8
|
4
|
100%
|
100%
|
|
Arkansas
|
10
|
8
|
110.3
|
96.6
|
105.4
|
95.1
|
3
|
65%
|
55%
|
|
Mississippi
|
8
|
10
|
106.6
|
96.8
|
111.6
|
93.3
|
1
|
58%
|
60%
|
|
Missouri
|
8
|
10
|
106.8
|
97.0
|
114.5
|
93.9
|
3
|
39%
|
37%
|
|
Auburn
|
7
|
11
|
104.5
|
98.7
|
96.8
|
100.2
|
2
|
50%
|
47%
|
|
Texas A&M
|
6
|
12
|
101.2
|
96.2
|
103.1
|
96.8
|
3
|
63%
|
60%
|
|
S. Carolina
|
6
|
12
|
104.8
|
100.2
|
98.8
|
104.4
|
3
|
45%
|
50%
|
|
Georgia
|
5
|
13
|
99.4
|
96.5
|
101.2
|
94.9
|
0
|
57%
|
58%
|
|
Mississippi St.
|
4
|
14
|
94.3
|
95.3
|
89.9
|
99.5
|
0
|
96%
|
97%
|
For a list of column definitions, click here.
Kentucky: Even if Kentucky is young, I completely agree with the model’s conclusion that this is the No. 1 team in the nation. The roster is full of instant impact Top 20 recruits, and even if a few don’t pan out, there is so much depth that it won’t matter. Probably the only place where Kentucky doesn’t have great depth is the back-court, so only an injury or poor play by Andrew or Aaron Harrison could derail the team’s season.
But let’s not get carried away with the undefeated talk either. Even if SEC basketball is in a down period, there are enough quality teams and differences in styles of play that the odds still favor the Wildcats tripping up a few times in conference play.
Florida: There seems to be a clear consensus that Kentucky, Louisville, and Michigan St. are the top three teams in the nation. But this week Florida added Rutger’s transfer Eli Carter. And while there is no guarantee that Carter should be eligible immediately, if the Arsalan Kazemi situation is any indication, I think there is a good chance Carter will be eligible to play next season. After the mistreatment of players at Rutgers, I think the NCAA will be hesitant to turn down a waiver request. And since Eli Carter gives the Gators another perimeter scorer (one of the team’s only question-markets), the model now likes them to jump ahead of Louisville for third nationally.
And looking at the roster, I cannot help but agree. Florida goes two deep at basically every position. There is basically no downside risk for this roster. Is Scottie Wilbekin or Top 10 recruit Kasey Hill the better PG. It doesn’t matter, they can play together. Should they be joined by hot-shooting Michael Frazier or Eli Carter? And what about the front-court? Will Top 20 recruit Chris Walker and South Carolina transfer Damontre Harris be able to earn playing time with Patrick Young and Will Yeguete coming back? And Casey Prather and Virginia Tech transfer Dorian Finney-Smith are plenty good too. Honestly, who is the weakest player in that 10-man rotation? All 10 of those guys are SEC-caliber starters. Is it any wonder why DeVon Walker and Cody Larson transferred out? They weren’t even going to have a chance to play this year.
Alabama: Alabama point-guard Trevor Releford remains a true star and Levi Randolph is still becoming one. But the biggest improvement should be in the front-court. With former #22 recruit Devonta Pollard becoming a sophomore, I expect a big jump in his efficiency. It will help that Pollard will be joined in the front-court by Top 100 recruits Jimmy Taylor and Shannon Hale. The team also adds a JUCO transfer Algie Key. Combine that talent with Anthony Grant’s ability to teach defense and you have a solid NCAA tournament team. Before Trevor Lacey transferred, I had Alabama in the preseason Top 25.
Tennessee: This week Tennessee lost PG Trae Golden. While the university cannot issue a formal statement, it is likely he is leaving because of academic issues. Cuonzo Martin went on the offensive with reporters and tried to claim that his team’s expectations shouldn’t slip without Golden. But that is ludicrous. Golden had an ORtg of 110 and 107 the last two seasons and that kind of veteran offensive efficiency at the PG spot is very hard to replace. The team is now projected to start unranked freshman point-guard Darius Thompson and I project Thompson to have an ORtg of 97. No matter what Cuonzo Martin says, freshmen simply make more turnovers and mistakes. Overall, Tennessee’s offensive projection drops from 115 to 109 thanks to Golden’s departure. Like Alabama, Tennessee fell out of my preseason Top 25.
LSU: Second year head coach Johnny Jones has upgraded the quality of recruiting with Top 100 players Jarrell Martin, Jordan Mickey, and Tim Quarterman joining the fold. He has also added JUCO transfer John Odo to provide size in the paint, just in case Mickey and Martin aren’t ready to lead from day one. And that added talent should help high volume shooter and high potential forward Johnny O’Bryant improve his efficiency. With Anthony Hickey returning to man the PG slot and Andre Stringer knocking down threes, LSU has a solid rotation on paper. But LSU is still a bubble team. And with all those new players playing major minutes, expect some puzzling losses at times this season.
Vanderbilt: A year after losing everyone to graduation, Vanderbilt returns their entire rotation. The team also adds Top 100 recruit Damian Jones and Tulsa transfer Eric McCllelan. With some normal player development, Vanderbilt will be better. But Kedren Johnson is the only player who looks like he might be a star.
Arkansas: With Hunter Mickelson transferring and Marshawn Powell and BJ Young declaring for the draft, it sure feels like Arkansas is headed in the wrong direction. And with Young departing, the team has a glaring need at PG. Arkansas made a play for Rutgers transfer Jerome Seagers but Seagers chose Auburn. Probably the only thing that could make Razorbacks fans feel worse than losing three key players unexpectedly was losing out on a player to Auburn. Still, if you are expecting Arkansas to fall off the map, the recruiting class will probably stop that from happening. Bobby Portis is an instant impact recruit in the post, and Moses Kingsley will provide some key minutes as well. Houston transfer Alandise Harris will also chip in this season. And Mike Anderson is a solid coach. But the recent string of departures is disheartening.
Ole Miss: The back-court of Marshall Henderson and Jarvis Summers is back but the other three starters are gone. And without a slew of elite recruits (either new or incumbent on the roster), replacing those missing players will be difficult. In the front court, the return of DeMarco Cox may help, but he is the kind of player that never shoots the basketball unless wide-open, and coming off an injury he certainly does not project as a big-time scorer. The same can be said for Aaron Jones who was also rather passive last season. And that means unranked freshmen recruits like Dwight Coleby and Sebastian Saiz will play more than Andy Kennedy would probably like.
Last season was head coach Andy Kennedy’s best defensive season of his career. But Murphy Holloway, the team’s best ball thief, and Reginald Buckner, the team’s best shot-blocker, are gone. And unless they can duplicate that kind of defensive performance, they probably won’t have enough offense to make the NCAA tournament. Aaron Jones was a solid shot-blocker in limited minutes last season, so another strong defensive season is possible, but certainly not probable.
Missouri: While Missouri can put together a pretty solid rotation of 7 players, the team will struggle to replace so many star players. PG Wes Clark is a Top 100 recruit and he will start from Day 1, but he is no Phil Pressey. Johnathan Williams is another Top 100 recruit and JUCO transfer Keanau Post was a Top 10 JUCO player. But neither projects at Laurence Bowers or Alex Oriakhi’s level. Perhaps the only player who can match last year’s quality is Tulsa transfer Jordan Clarkson who can probably match what Keion Bell brought to the team last year. But if Missouri is going to have any chance of matching last year, they are going to need one of the three returning players to step up their game. And while Earnest Ross and Tony Criswell will be nice pieces, the player most likely to break out is Jabari Brown. Brown was a Top 20 recruit out of high school, and joined the team mid-season last year. With a full fall of games under his belt, perhaps Brown can reach that next level. But his development won’t make up for what the team loses. And given Frank Haith’s struggles at teaching defense, the tournament seems unlikely.
Auburn: I’m assuming Rutgers transfer Jerome Seagers will get a waiver to play right away. Seagers and Virginia transfer KT Harrell will join Chris Denson and Jordan Price to form a passable SEC back-court. But the lack of talent in the front-court will keep this team near the bottom of the SEC.
Texas A&M: PG Fabyon Harris and forward Kourtney Roberson are fantastic players. But the rest of the roster is hideously inefficient. Normally I’d talk about how former Top 100 recruits Alex Caruso and J-Mychal Reese are poised for a breakout sophomore season. But after they posted ORtgs of 88 and 83 last year, it would take a minor miracle for them to become dependable players next season. And Florida St. transfer Antwan Space looked ill-equipped to play major college ball in his short time at that school too.
South Carolina: My model still loves what Frank Martin did at Kansas St. He was a consistent winner, and other than his first season, he did it without a roster full of elite talent. This Post & Courier story about the night SC’s Brenton Williams scored 38 points summed up Martin’s views perfectly. “My whole thing is, I don’t care what your talent level is. That’s irrelevant to me. I don’t care if you have 96 stars. I don’t care if somebody rated you a 99… I watch guys play 50 times over a course of a year, including summer basketball, and I still don’t know if they’re good enough. How people can watch somebody play three times and determine whether they’re a three-star, four-star, I don’t get that. I don’t care how many stars you’ve got. I don’t care who you are. I don’t care what your talent level is. Bring some positive energy every day.” Martin inherited a rag-tag bunch of players that went 2-14 the previous year and believed he could win with that group because he had done it before. But last year a coach who had never had a defensive performance outside the top 50, suddenly coached a team to the 228th best defense in the nation. His team was hard-nosed and physical as always, committing fouls at a record pace. But unlike most seasons, that didn’t translate to a hard-nosed two-point defense. Instead of fouling to stop lay-ups, South Carolina fouled and allowed lay-ups.
The real problem was the lack of size and depth in the front-court. Michael Carrera was an under-sized rebounding machine (much like Colorado St.’s Pierce Hornung), but he wasn’t the type of guy who could anchor the defense. It hurt the team that Carlton Geathers was injured. It also hurt that RJ Slawson could never live up to Frank Martin’s high expectations. (I wasn’t even remotely shocked to see that Slawson transferred this off-season) But that meant the focus had to be on freshmen front-court players, and they weren’t ready.
Bruce Ellington (when he returns from football), Sindarius Thornwell (the top 100 recruit), Ty Johnson (the mid-season Villanova transfer who struggled mightily for Jay Wright), and Brenton Williams (efficient but as Martin put it “he might be slower than me”) all provide something. And ideally Carrera could play more minutes at small-forward (at least defensively). But the 5 other players competing for time in the front-court have nearly equivalently low expectations. And that means no matter what Frank Martin has accomplished in the past, the turnaround will take time.
Georgia: When Georgia hired Mark Fox, I thought he was a great hire. But with Gerald Robinson graduating and Ketavious Caldwell-Pope leaving in the draft, there is literally nothing left. There are no Top 100 recruits left on the roster. There are no obvious stars.
Mississippi St.: Everyone is back. But last year’s team was so horrible that even with substantial improvement on offense and defense, this is still by far the worst team in the SEC.
Eli Carter, Trae Golden, Kentucky Wildcats, Florida Gators, Alabama Crimson Tide, Tennessee Volunteers, LSU Tigers, Vanderbilt Commodores, Arkansas Razorbacks, Mississippi State Bulldogs, Ole Miss Rebels, Missouri Tigers, Auburn Tigers, Texas A&M Aggies, South Carolina Gamecocks, Georgia Bulldogs, Southeastern Conference, NCAA Apr 08, 2013 12:17 AM EDT
Last fall on Basketball Prospectus I introduced the first ever lineup-based predictions model. Even -though I intend to make improvements to the model over the summer, since I already have the programming code written, today I wanted to rerun the first version of the model and see what it tells us about the 2013-2014 season.
The biggest problem is guessing which players will declare for the draft. I haven’t seen an official announcement for Nerlens Noel or Shabazz Muhammad, but I think it is clear they are both leaving. I also assume that anyone who can make this year’s lottery would be foolish not to leave. Thus I assume Ben McLemore, Marcus Smart, Victor Oladipo, Otto Porter, and Trey Burke are gone. Michael Carter-Williams never struck me as an obvious lottery choice this year, but the consensus seems to be that the scouts like his size and NCAA tournament play, so I project him as leaving. Similarly a slew of big guys seem likely to go pro from Gorgui Dieng, to Cody Zeller, to Alex Len, to Kelly Olynyk.
Notably, I’m not going to assume Doug McDermott and Russ Smith come back. I understand there isn’t much more they can accomplish in college, but based on the draft projections I have seen, neither player is guaranteed to be a first round pick right now. I think that if you are not certain to get a guaranteed contract in the NBA, the risk of leaving is pretty high. Thus I’m going to assume these players return, even though that may be a dubious conclusion.
|
Rank
|
Team
|
Conf
|
Pred Off
|
Pred Def
|
Pred Pyth
|
Ret Min
|
Ret Poss
|
T100
|
Last Pyth
|
|
1
|
Kentucky
|
SEC
|
120.8
|
92.5
|
0.9391
|
44%
|
43%
|
10
|
0.8171
|
|
2
|
Michigan St.
|
B10
|
114.1
|
87.6
|
0.9374
|
83%
|
84%
|
8
|
0.9361
|
|
3
|
N. Carolina
|
ACC
|
115.9
|
89.0
|
0.9371
|
86%
|
88%
|
11
|
0.8676
|
|
4
|
Louisville
|
AAC
|
110.9
|
86.0
|
0.9314
|
72%
|
72%
|
7
|
0.9767
|
|
5
|
Florida
|
SEC
|
110.5
|
86.6
|
0.9246
|
57%
|
54%
|
9
|
0.9696
|
|
6
|
Michigan
|
B10
|
115.7
|
91.2
|
0.9193
|
79%
|
71%
|
6
|
0.9467
|
|
7
|
Arizona
|
P12
|
113.4
|
90.8
|
0.9070
|
56%
|
52%
|
9
|
0.9089
|
|
8
|
Marquette
|
BE
|
113.9
|
92.4
|
0.8945
|
61%
|
64%
|
7
|
0.8744
|
|
9
|
Duke
|
ACC
|
111.6
|
90.6
|
0.8939
|
58%
|
50%
|
10
|
0.9441
|
|
10
|
Wisconsin
|
B10
|
108.1
|
88.1
|
0.8900
|
58%
|
55%
|
3
|
0.9308
|
Key:
Pred Off, Pred Def, Pred Pythag: The predicted points scored and allowed per 100 possessions, and predicted winning percentage against an average D1 team on a neutral floor.
Returning Minutes, Possessions: The loss of high possession players can be a larger detriment to the offense, thus I list percentage of returning possessions in addition to returning minutes.
T100: Number of players who were Top 100 recruits out of high school. People focus on Top 100 freshmen, but Top 100 players are also more likely to become breakout stars later in their career.
Last Pythag: Last year’s Pythagorean winning percentage according to Kenpom.com. This is essentially a measure of each team’s margin-of-victory in 2012-13.
Kentucky: The Wildcats have the most talent by far, and the most NBA potential, by far. The only question is time. Can John Calipari teach such a wide array of talent to play together in one year? In three of his four years, John Calipari has managed to get the Wildcats to play elite defense. The model hedges its bets and says the defense might not come together that quickly. (The fact that defense-lacking Kyle Witjer is still going to play meaningful minutes is also a concern.) But with all those Top 20 recruits, and all those highly ranked returning sophomores, it is very hard to predict anything other than a special offensive team.
Michigan St.: I’m assuming Gary Harris is coming back based on Tom Izzo’s comments. When a Top 10 Big Ten squad returns basically all its key players, it is hard not to have high expectations. Kenny Kaminski will be healthy. Denzel Valentine and Matt Costello both remain high potential guys who should see a sophomore leap in efficiency. And Harris, Keith Appling, Branden Dawson, and Adreian Payne are as good a returning set of four starters as you will find. Michigan St. might not be the most talented team in the country, but they have fewer lineup questions than just about anyone.
North Carolina: The Tar Heels will be back. The two biggest lineup issues this year were point-guard and one of the forward slots. We already saw glimpses of point guard Marcus Paige’s improved play late in the year and he should be a star in year two. I can’t tell you exactly who will develop as a post compliment to James McAdoo, but someone will. Whether it will be freshman Isaiah Hicks or Kennedy Meeks, or (after a summer of working out in the gym) Brice Johnson or Joel James, the Tar Heels have four former elite high school post players to choose from. At least one of them will be ready. Overall, North Carolina has more Top 100 talent than anyone else.
Louisville: With players like Montrezl Harrell playing well in limited time this year, Louisville has a chance to go to the Final Four again. But this high ranking depends on Russ Smith’s return. Without Smith, the team will be putting a heavy burden on incoming freshman point guard Terry Rozier. Rozier isn’t in this year’s ESPN’s Top 100 because he needed a year of prep school, but he was a consensus Top 100 recruit last year. RSCI had him 75th.
Florida: Don’t be scared away because the Gators return only 54% of their offense from last year. The Gators add two instant impact recruitsin Kasey Hill and Chris Walker, along with two transfers who were former Top 100 players, Damontre Harris and Dorian Finney-Smith. If the point-guard Hill lives up to his hype, Florida might be even better than last year. They will certainly be deeper.
Michigan: The further development of Mitch McGary, Glen Robinson, and the addition of another stellar recruiting class should help overcome the loss of Trey Burke. But if additional players declare for the draft, Michigan’s expectations could slip.
Arizona: My gut tells me Arizona may be a little too low here. Arizona loses a lot of production, but they have the right pieces coming in. Point guard TJ McConnell was phenomenal at Duquesne and unlike Mark Lyons, McConnell is more of a natural PG. Aaron Gordon and Rondae Hollis-Jefferson should be instant-impact recruits. And the returning sophomores on the front line should be better in year two. The model is mostly concerned whether Sean Miller can bring together an elite defensive team. Last year was Miller’s best defensive team yet, but it still wasn’t an elite defensive team. Until Miller gets his team to play great defense for a full season, there will always be reasons to be skeptical.
Marquette: Vander Blue, Davante Gardner, and Jamil Wilson are back. Buzz Williams has his best recruiting class yet, and the team should have more Top 100 talent than it has ever had in his tenure. Plus Buzz Williams gets the most out of his players by studying the data and eliminating bad possessions. Still, even if the model likes Marquette as a top 10 team, I am concerned that Williams typically has a short-leash with his freshmen. And if they don’t contribute, Marquette may still lack the talent to be an elite team.
Duke: Quinn Cook hasn’t been dominant yet, but he was a Top 10 recruit out of high school, and he is still a high potential player. Andre Dawkins should return from his sabbatical and paired with Rasheed Sulaimon on the perimeter, the Duke back-court looks strong. In the front-court, Amile Jefferson was a solid offensive player when filling in for Ryan Kelly and Jabari Parker is an instant impact recruit. And don’t overlook Mississippi St. transfer Rodney Hood. Duke loses a lot, but the lineup still looks dominant.
Wisconsin: Once again, a model based on the tempo free numbers loves Bo Ryan’s squad. I’m skeptical, but the lineup does look legitimate next year. Remember Josh Gasser is coming back after missing all of last year with an injury. The team’s most important scorer Ben Brust is back. Frank Kaminsky played well in limited minutes. And most importantly, Sam Dekker might be the best post player Bo Ryan has ever had. Seriously, the Badgers lose 45% of their possessions from last year, and the tempo free model still loves them.
Click here for Teams 11 to 25.
Gary Harris, Kentucky Wildcats, Michigan State Spartans, North Carolina Tar Heels, Louisville Cardinals, Florida Gators, Michigan Wolverines, Arizona Wildcats, Marquette Golden Eagles, Duke Blue Devils, Wisconsin Badgers, NCAA Mar 05, 2013 1:48 PM EST Oregon, North Dakota St., Florida and Duke all got key players back recently and given how these teams performed without these players, the returns could not have come at a better time. In the following splits, I replicate the formula used on Ken Pomeroy’s website, adjusting for opponent and venue.
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
Oregon (without Dominic Artis)
|
101.3
|
88.9
|
6
|
4
|
0.7920
|
|
Oregon
|
107.8
|
86.8
|
17
|
2
|
0.9027
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
North Dakota St. (without Taylor Braun)
|
97.3
|
89.9
|
5
|
5
|
0.6925
|
|
North Dakota St.
|
106.3
|
91.4
|
15
|
3
|
0.8251
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Florida (no Will Yeguete)
|
116.9
|
87.0
|
4
|
2
|
0.9537
|
|
Florida
|
122.1
|
81.3
|
19
|
3
|
0.9849
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Duke (without Ryan Kelly)
|
119.7
|
95.0
|
9
|
4
|
0.9143
|
|
Duke
|
119.7
|
83.8
|
16
|
0
|
0.9746
|
Oregon’s 17-2 record with Dominic Artis sounds a little better than it actually is. The Ducks played a relatively weak non-conference schedule, and even with Artis in the lineup, Oregon was not blowing teams out like some of the other elite teams. But there is no question Oregon has been a better team with Artis healthy. This Pythagorean rating suggests the Ducks have been the 19th best team in the nation with Artis in the lineup.
North Dakota St. should be one of the most fascinating teams to watch in the smaller conference tournaments. With Taylor Braun healthy, the Bison were a legitimate challenger to Nate Wolters South Dakota St. team and Western Illinois for the Summit league title. Without him, they simply lacked the offensive punch to compete with quality teams.
Florida’s defense did sag with Will Yeguete out, but Michael Frazier was also out in the Tennessee game, so it might not have been all Yeguete.
Finally, according to these numbers, when Duke has been healthy, only a healthy Florida has been more capable of blowing teams out. And given that Duke is undefeated with a healthy Ryan Kelly (against a quality non-conference schedule), you can expect a lot of people to start saying that Duke is now the favorite to cut down the nets in March.
But before we get completely on the Duke bandwagon, I want to express a word of caution by pointing to the following teams. All of these teams have integrated key pieces back into the lineup, and it has not always worked according to plan:
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
UNLV (without Khem Birch)
|
109.7
|
85.2
|
5
|
1
|
0.9306
|
|
UNLV (Moser out or limited)
|
108.3
|
91.3
|
7
|
1
|
0.8525
|
|
UNLV (Moser post injury)
|
106.0
|
87.7
|
9
|
5
|
0.8751
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Wichita St. (healthy early season)
|
108.8
|
88.8
|
9
|
1
|
0.8889
|
|
Wichita St. (3 rotation players injured)
|
108.8
|
89.1
|
6
|
1
|
0.8856
|
|
Wichita St. (Carl Hall returns)
|
108.9
|
91.6
|
9
|
5
|
0.8550
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Syracuse
|
111.8
|
80.7
|
15
|
1
|
0.9661
|
|
Syracuse (without James Southerland)
|
119.3
|
91.9
|
4
|
2
|
0.9355
|
|
Syracuse (Southerland returns)
|
115.0
|
92.2
|
3
|
4
|
0.9054
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Providence (missing players)
|
102.9
|
90.1
|
8
|
4
|
0.7973
|
|
Providence (January)
|
111.7
|
98.8
|
2
|
7
|
0.7800
|
|
Providence (February and March)
|
108.3
|
91.3
|
6
|
1
|
0.8527
|
First, one of my big concerns is that injured players do not always return and play at their former level. Mike Moser has clearly been a shell of himself since returning to the UNLV lineup full-time. He showed signs of life in his last game against Nevada, but the reality is that sometimes injuries can take away a player’s explosiveness.
The fact that Ryan Kelly scored 36 points in his return should alleviate some of those concerns, but not all of them. I think Robbie Hummel is the ideal example. Hummel came back and continued to be an explosive scorer for Purdue last season. But I don’t think he ever regained the defensive form he showed as a junior.
The differences are pretty small here, but Wichita St. may also be informative in this regard. The Shockers lost 3 players to injury mid-season and remarkably kept their same level of performance. But since Carl Hall has returned the defense has slipped slightly.
And sometimes it has nothing to do with an injury at all. Sometimes teams simply struggle to regain chemistry after an absence. I think we are all shocked that James Southerland’s return has not been a boost for Syracuse. But the Orange have played their worst basketball of the season since Southerland has returned. Sure, a lot of that came against quality competition. But I don’t think anyone expected Syracuse to lose two straight games at home.
And it can take time to build that chemistry. Providence was a depleted team early in the year with Vincent Council, Kris Dunn, and Bryce Cotton all missing games for various reasons. But the early season team was committed to playing lock-down defense to stay competitive. When the offensive stars returned, the defensive intensity just wasn’t the same. Only after a disastrous January did Providence players realize that they needed talent on offense and effort on defense in order to be a quality Big East squad. And for the last month, Providence has been playing like the 40th best team in the nation. That’s still the level of play of a bubble team, and based on the overall resume, Providence isn’t a legitimate at-large team at this point. But watch out for the Friars in the Big East tournament this year.
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
Boise St.
|
109.5
|
102.6
|
2
|
5
|
0.6601
|
|
Boise St. (Full Strength)
|
113.4
|
94.6
|
16
|
3
|
0.8657
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Miami
|
102.7
|
89.2
|
8
|
3
|
0.8095
|
|
Miami (Full Strength)
|
115.8
|
85.7
|
15
|
2
|
0.9566
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Missouri
|
109.0
|
93.0
|
11
|
4
|
0.8363
|
|
Missouri (Full Strength)
|
123.4
|
95.7
|
10
|
4
|
0.9312
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
San Diego St. (without Xavier Thames)
|
103.6
|
97.3
|
2
|
2
|
0.6551
|
|
San Diego St.
|
109.8
|
86.7
|
16
|
6
|
0.9181
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Michigan (Jordan Morgan out or limited)
|
118.9
|
94.5
|
4
|
3
|
0.9132
|
|
Michigan
|
122.8
|
91.0
|
19
|
2
|
0.9558
|
Boise St. has been climbing into brackets this week, and you might look at their ranking of 51 on kenpom.com and think they are not all that deserving. But Jeff Elorriaga, Mikey Thompson, Igor Hadziomerovic, Derrick Marks, and Kenny Buckner have all missed games this year including some key losses for the Broncos. When fully healthy, Boise St. has been the 33rd best team in the nation.
I’ve made the point about Miami and Missouri before (as those absences happened early in the year), but those teams have clearly been better when fully healthy. But don’t forget that San Diego St.’s Xavier Thames has also been absent (with back problems) at times this season. All of these teams have looked better when at full strength.
Finally, Michigan’s loss to Penn St. occurred even with Jordan Morgan playing significant minutes. So the Wolverines aren’t a perfect team with him. But he can be a difference maker on defense, and when Michigan had to play him sparingly (or not at all) for seven games, the Wolverines were clearly playing less impressive basketball.
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
UCLA
|
110.4
|
91.9
|
6
|
1
|
0.8673
|
|
UCLA (with current rotation)
|
112.6
|
94.2
|
16
|
6
|
0.8627
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Notre Dame
|
118.0
|
98.6
|
14
|
4
|
0.8636
|
|
Notre Dame (without Scott Martin)
|
113.2
|
95.0
|
8
|
3
|
0.8588
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Texas
|
95.6
|
87.1
|
10
|
12
|
0.7212
|
|
Texas (with Myck Kabongo)
|
113.8
|
103.7
|
4
|
3
|
0.7223
|
Lineup changes have not made a huge difference for every team. UCLA has been missing Shabazz Muhammad, David Wear, and Travis Wear at times this season, but managed to fill in when those players were absent. UCLA’s middling margin-of-victory stats are not the result of injuries.
Notre Dame lost Scott Martin, but it was a mixed bag. Martin’s scoring has clearly been missed, but an injured Martin was a defensive liability, and Notre Dame has compensated by playing better defense since Martin went down.
Finally, Texas has clearly been a much more explosive offensive team since Myck Kabongo joined the team. But the team has completely let up defensively now that Kabongo has returned. If Texas wants to have any chance of making a run in the Big 12 tournament, they have to combine the defensive intensity they had for most of the year, with the more efficient offense now that the team has a point guard.
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
St. Louis
|
106.5
|
90.9
|
8
|
3
|
0.8359
|
|
St. Louis (with Kwamain Mitchell)
|
110.8
|
88.0
|
15
|
2
|
0.9138
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Virginia
|
108.4
|
89.6
|
7
|
2
|
0.8760
|
|
Virginia (with Jontel Evans)
|
110.5
|
87.6
|
13
|
7
|
0.9154
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
La Salle
|
110.1
|
97.1
|
6
|
1
|
0.7838
|
|
La Salle (with Tyrone Garland)
|
109.7
|
92.9
|
14
|
6
|
0.8469
|
It is easy to look at Kwamain Mitchell’s and Jontel Evan’s poor ORtg and claim that these players could not be responsible for their team’s turnaround. But keep in mind that these players did not get to pad their own stats against weak non-conference competition. And also keep in mind that having a quality point-guard can be vital to an offense even if that player doesn’t shoot all that well.
Virginia Tech transfer Tyrone Garland is not getting enough publicity nationally. Since he has joined La Salle, the team has started playing like a true NCAA tournament contender.
|
Team
|
Adj Off
|
Adj Def
|
W
|
L
|
Pyth.
|
|
Georgetown
|
97.9
|
84.3
|
10
|
3
|
0.8232
|
|
Georgetown (without Greg Whittington)
|
113.1
|
84.9
|
13
|
1
|
0.9499
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Kentucky
|
112.0
|
89.2
|
17
|
7
|
0.9116
|
|
Kentucky (without Nerlens Noel)
|
113.2
|
104.8
|
3
|
2
|
0.6875
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
North Carolina
|
107.6
|
91.0
|
15
|
7
|
0.8472
|
|
North Carolina (committed to smaller lineup)
|
119.4
|
89.2
|
5
|
1
|
0.9519
|
I’m not quite sure I buy Georgetown as a 1-seed in the NCAA tournament. But they have played like the 5th best team in the nation since Greg Whittington went down. Once the Hoyas realized that they needed to run the offense through Otto Porter, the offense has been substantially better.
I don’t quite think Kentucky is this bad without Nerlens Noel. They did pick up a quality win against Missouri without him. But the margin-of-victory numbers aren’t convinced because even the Missouri victory was by a small margin at home.
And I want to end by talking about North Carolina. In the preseason I wrote, “If they choose to go four-guards around James McAdoo, they could attempt to replicate what Missouri did last year, and be plenty effective.” And starting with the Duke game, Roy Williams finally committed to that strategy. For the last six games, North Carolina has gone with a smaller lineup and started playing like the 5th best team in the country. The amazing part is that their defense hasn’t even dropped off with the smaller lineup. Perhaps this isn’t sustainable. Teams may be able to adjust to North Carolina’s new strategy and attack the Tar Heels more effectively. But if North Carolina keeps this up, they may be a legitimate Final Four threat after all.
Final Notes:
I discussed some injuries earlier this season. Click here for more details. A few recent notes on players:
-Steven Adams missed Pittsburgh's narrow OT win over Villanova. His sprained left ankle is worth watching.
-UConn’s Shabazz Napier was injured in the OT loss at Georgetown and missed UConn's loss against Cincinnati.
-Iowa’s Mike Gesell injured his ankle and missed the end of the Nebraska loss, and has now missed the last two games. If Iowa wants to make a late season run, they need him in the lineup.
Other minor injury points
-Rodney Williams was out in Minnesota's home loss to Illinois.
-Lorenzo Brown missed NC State's February losses to Miami and Duke.
-Nick Williams missed Mississippi's loss to Florida.
-Andrew Smith missed Butler's loss at Charlotte.
-Pe'Shon Howard missed one of Maryland's losses to Florida St.
-Trae Golden was out in Tennessee's losses at Arkansas and vs Georgia.
-Juwan Hoard Jr. missed Detroit's loss at Wichita St.
-Finally, Stony Brook’s Anthony Jackson did not play in the loss against Vermont.
Feb 26, 2013 In this edition, we take the teams in the Top 16 of the Pomeroy Rankings and figure out how often they look beatable on the basketball court. Feb 12, 2013 While there are certainly no elite college teams this season, there are a host of teams that can reach the Final Four. In this edition, we outline the various tiers. Dec 17, 2012 On the legitimacy of Arizona and Florida as national championship contenders, who has quality wins already and more. Dec 03, 2012 On Nerlens Noel, Isaiah Austin, Kyle Anderson and the rest of the freshman class as they play such prominent roles to begin the 12-13 NCAA season. Nov 07, 2012 Because of the large correlation between talent-on-hand and coaching, discrepancies usually only exist when a coaches ability doesn’t match up with who he has in the lineup. Here are some teams whose rankings would change meaningfully if coaching effects were ignored. Mar 26, 2012 Don't let the final score fool you. Kansas vs North Carolina was an instant classic. Mar 21, 2012 The first weekend of the NCAA Tournament was one of the most unpredictable in recent memory. Now, with the second weekend set to tip-off, the Madness may have only just begun. Mar 12, 2012 A few preliminary thoughts on matchups and which teams will advance deep in the tournament. Mar 09, 2012 While personnel determine scheme in the NBA, college basketball coaches recruit players that fit their schemes. Feb 23, 2012 The best way to examine the value of specific college coaches is to examine how well they recruit and subsequently develop their talent. Let's examine the top 49 coaches from the Power 6 conferences. Feb 13, 2012 Thomas Robinson, J'Covan Brown, Meyers Leonard, Jamaal Franklin and Trae Golden are amongst the Top-20 Breakout Players in college basketball. Jan 30, 2012 Many have called this a down year for college basketball and though that argument can be made about elite teams, there are still plenty of reasons why it's a fallacy. Jan 09, 2012 On the first full weekend of conference play, there were 35 match-ups between BCS conference teams, which means the team that takes their information and executes better usually wins. Jan 02, 2012 Separating the BCS schools into tiers named after John Wooden, Dean Smith, Gene Keady, Rollie Massimino, John Chaney, Kelvin Sampson, Tim Welsh, Pat Knight and Sidney Lowe, how does everyone stand? Dec 27, 2011 Here is how various college teams such as Ohio State, Baylor, Pitt and Oregon have performed with and without key players. Dec 26, 2011 Duke, Kentucky, UCLA, Texas, Kansas, North Carolina, UConn, Florida and Arizona each begin the 11-12 NBA season with 10 or more players on NBA rosters. Nov 10, 2011 There are many ways to build a winning program. John Calipari’s focus on younger players may be the best way to get elite recruits, but it isn’t the only way to build a winning program. Older Articles » |
|
Basketball Wiretap Headlines
|