Since Kevin Garnett was taken in the lottery in the draft of 1995 the NBA has seen a steady flow of high school seniors skipping college and jumping straight into the big league. While many of these players have blossomed into superstars - Kobe Bryant, Tracy McGrady, Jermaine O'Neal to name a few - people quickly forget that each took their lumps before growing into the athletes we see today.
While Amare Stoudemire thus far has been producing in Phoenix during his first season, last year's crop which saw three of the first four picks coming straight from their proms have been struggling. Kwame Brown and Eddy Curry were both benched by their respective teams after starting the season out strongly, while Tyson Chandler has been struggling with consistency and foul trouble and now finds himself coming off the bench for Curry. This goes without mentioning DeSagana Diop, the high school center also taken in the lottery by the Cleveland Cavaliers who has yet to register a pulse.
The fact of the matter is many of these players simply are not ready for the bigtime. The time spent "learning the ropes" in the NBA could have been better off spent doing the very same thing in college, the only difference is they would be actually playing decent minutes there while earning an education. Bill Cartwright, the coach of the Chicago Bulls who possesses two such players, agrees.
"Even though we have two young guys, I'm not a big fan of bringing high school guys into the league," Cartwright said. "I think it says to the other kids of lesser talent that instead of maybe going to college and graduating, they want to go to the NBA. I don't feel like these kids are ready for that, physically or emotionally. I'd like to see a college limit, two years" before being allowed in the NBA."
Cartwright's complaint is more to do with the hype surrounding sensation Lebron James than either of his giants. With NBA teams falling over themselves for chances to acquire the phenom via the NBA lottery James' games are now being broadcast on pay-per-view cable in Ohio and James will now be on national TV this week (12th December, ESPN2).
Sam Smith of the Chicago Tribune quotes Bulls forward Jalen Rose as all the attention being yet another example of young athletes being exploited.
"There's a lot of good that can come out of airing high school games on pay-per-view," he said. "Exposure for the high school, for some of the players, exposure for some on the coaching staff to possibly get college jobs. But that's 5 percent of it.
"The other 95 percent is, who gets the money? The bottom line is everyone is making money on the backs of [high school] athletes. It affects players tremendously. Now they're looking at being pros in high school, feeling they can do the same things in high school that they could in college, playing on national TV, having your name called around the country. Anyone who says they're not exploiting 16- and 17-year-olds isn't being realistic."