Cody Zeller had 16 points, eight rebounds, three steals and two blocks in Indiana's 75-59 win over Butler.
"He is a guy who can score around the rim and shoot," said Butler coach Brad Stevens. "Even though he shot one short, he is still a great shooter. I think he is one of the most unselfish guys you can have come in and be a star."
Indiana is now 6-0 for the season.
Zeller is averaging 20.2 points, 10.4 rebounds and 3.6 steals per 36 minutes on 72.5% shooting from the floor.