| School | Nickname | Location | Season Joined | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Baldwin Wallace Yellow Jackets | Yellow Jackets | Berea, OH | N/A |
|
Capital University (OH) Crusaders | Crusaders | Bexley, OH | N/A |
|
Heidelberg Student Princes | Student Princes | Tiffin, OH | N/A |
|
Marietta College (OH) Pioneers | Pioneers | Marietta, OH | N/A |
|
Mount Union Raiders | Raiders | Alliance, OH | N/A |
|
Muskingum Fighting Muskies | Fighting Muskies | New Concord, OH | N/A |
|
Ohio Northern Polar Bears | Polar Bears | Ada, OH | N/A |
|
Otterbein Cardinals | Cardinals | Westerville, OH | N/A |
|
Wilmington (OH) Quakers | Quakers | Wilmington, OH | N/A |
Ohio Athletic Conference
