The Many Facets & Unpredictability Of March Madness
Jonathan Tjarks
Mar 9, 2012 12:13 AM
The older I get, the more I see that one of the things I love most about sports is the variety of it, the diversity of it and the CHARACTERS. Men’s tennis is at its best in many years because, for the first time in a long time, the top three or four players all have wildly different styles. The Tim Tebow story was fun on so many levels, but one of those levels was that he was just SO DIFFERENT in how he played — I’d say we are entering a great time for quarterbacks, because Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers and Eli Manning and Drew Brees and Michael Vick and Cam Newton and Tebow and others are not really alike at all.
-- Joe Posnanski
As a basketball fan, I’ve never understood the division that exists between fans of the NBA and the NCAA. While the NBA has the best basketball players in the world, March Madness is compelling in its own right and as entertaining as anything that happens on the professional level.
In the NBA, the owners of the 30 franchises consider turning a profit and getting an equal shot at the top players a right, regardless of how well (or how poorly) they run their organization and the respective size of their fan-bases. Since every losing team is a few ping pong balls from the rights to a LeBron James, Kevin Durant or Dwight Howard, personnel determines scheme in the NBA.
In contrast, the vast majority of the 344 Division I programs in college basketball have little chance of ever receiving a commitment from a McDonald’s All-American. But instead of petulantly trying to sabotage the sport in a misguided effort to legislate fairness, schools try many creative ways of leveraging the talents of the players they can recruit. As a result, scheme determines personnel in the NCAA.
At Syracuse, Jim Boeheim has made a Hall of Fame career out of running a contrarian scheme, in his case an aggressive 2-3 zone. The Orange traditionally have rosters full of “1.5’s”, 6’3+ combo guards lacking the quickness to defend elite PG’s and the size to defend SG’s, and “3.5’s”, 6’8+ combo forwards lacking the quickness to defend elite SF’s and the size to defend PF’s. However, because Syracuse never plays man defense, the athletic deficiencies of their players are minimized.
So while nearly every NBA team runs a fairly similar system of isolations, pick-and-rolls and man defense, an incredibly diverse array of styles can be found in the college game. On one end of the spectrum, teams like Missouri play four guards and pressure the ball 94 feet for 48 minutes, on the other, teams like Wisconsin run a deliberate motion offense, trying to minimize the number of possessions and shoot at the very end of the shot-clock.
In the NBA, the players are too good for the “40 Minutes of Hell” system (which Mike Anderson has brought to Missouri and Arkansas in the last few years) to be successful. Like Mike Leach’s bizarre pass-happy offense in college football, Anderson’s system, which he learned as a member of Nolan Richardson’s staff in Arkansas in the 1990’s, has philosophical holes that professional athletes can exploit. Nevertheless, that doesn’t make them any less entertaining on the collegiate level.
And with 68 teams set to compete in the NCAA Tournament, there are a lot more surprises in the college game. Even programs ranked in the top-15 like Murray State have barely been on national TV this season.
We have a pretty good idea of how teams like the Pacers and the 76ers match up with the top of the Eastern Conference but not whether an undersized Murray State squad can handle the size of an elite team from a Power Six conference. It’s an open question how Isaiah Canaan’s speed and athleticism translates outside of the Ohio Valley Conference. Non-conference play in college basketball generally ends in late December, so it’s almost impossible to gauge how younger teams like Texas, Washington and Tennessee who have found their groove in the last two months will fare in March.
In the NBA, it’s hard to envision a scenario where Chicago, Miami and Oklahoma City aren’t three of the final four teams left in the playoffs. In the NCAA, as many as two dozen teams have a legitimate shot at making a run at the Final Four.
Of course, in terms of entertainment, none of this makes the NCAA necessarily better or worse than the NBA, just different. But, as Posnanski writes, there’s something to be said for the concept of “different” in the modern sports world. Basketball fans of all stripes should enjoy March Madness; the NBA will still be here in a few weeks.
Tags: Syracuse Orange, Charlotte 49ers, Dayton Flyers, Duquesne Dukes, Fordham Rams, George Washington Revolutionaries, La Salle Explorers, Massachusetts Minutemen, Rhode Island Rams, Richmond Spiders, Saint Joseph's Hawks, Saint Louis Billikens, St. Bonaventure Bonnies, Temple Owls, Xavier Musketeers, Belmont Bruins, East Tennessee State Buccaneers, Florida Gulf Coast Eagles, Jacksonville Dolphins, Kennesaw State Owls, Lipscomb Bisons, Mercer Bears, North Florida Ospreys, Stetson Hatters, USC Upstate Spartans, Boston College Eagles, Clemson Tigers, Duke Blue Devils, Florida State Seminoles, Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets, Maryland Terrapins, Miami (FL) Hurricanes, North Carolina Tar Heels, NC State Wolfpack, Virginia Tech Hokies, Virginia Cavaliers, Wake Forest Demon Deacons, Albany Great Danes, Binghamton Bearcats, Boston University Terriers, Hartford Hawks, Maine Black Bears, New Hampshire Wildcats, Stony Brook Seawolves, UMBC Retrievers, Vermont Catamounts, Baylor Bears, Iowa State Cyclones, Kansas Jayhawks, Kansas State Wildcats, Missouri Tigers, Oklahoma Sooners, Oklahoma State Cowboys, Texas Longhorns, Texas A&M Aggies, Texas Tech Red Raiders, Cincinnati Bearcats, UConn Huskies, DePaul Blue Demons, Georgetown Hoyas, Louisville Cardinals, Marquette Golden Eagles, Notre Dame Fighting Irish, Pittsburgh Panthers, Providence Friars, Rutgers Scarlet Knights, Seton Hall Pirates, South Florida Bulls, St. John's Red Storm, Villanova Wildcats, West Virginia Mountaineers, Eastern Washington Eagles, Idaho State Bengals, Montana Grizzlies, Montana State Fighting Bobcats, Northern Arizona Lumberjacks, Northern Colorado Bears, Portland State Vikings, Sacramento State Hornets, Weber State Wildcats, Campbell Fighting Camels, Charleston Southern Buccaneers, Coastal Carolina Chanticleers, Gardner-Webb Runnin' Bulldogs, High Point Panthers, Liberty Flames, UNC Asheville Bulldogs, Presbyterian Blue Hose, Radford Highlanders, Virginia Military Keydets, Winthrop Eagles, Illinois Fighting Illini, Indiana Hoosiers, Iowa Hawkeyes, Michigan Wolverines, Michigan State Spartans, Minnesota Golden Gophers, Nebraska Cornhuskers, Northwestern Wildcats, Ohio State Buckeyes, Penn State Nittany Lions, Purdue Boilermakers, Wisconsin Badgers, Cal Poly Mustangs, Cal State Fullerton Titans, Cal State Northridge Matadors, Long Beach State Beach, Pacific Tigers, UC Davis Aggies, UC Irvine Anteaters, UC Riverside Highlanders, UC Santa Barbara Gauchos, East Carolina Pirates, Houston Cougars, Marshall Thundering Herd, Memphis Tigers, Rice Owls, Southern Methodist Mustangs, Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles, Tulane Green Wave, Tulsa Golden Hurricane, UAB Blazers, UCF Knights, UTEP Miners, Delaware Fightin Blue Hens, Drexel Dragons, George Mason Patriots, Georgia State Panthers, Hofstra Pride, James Madison Dukes, UNC Wilmington Seahawks, Northeastern Huskies, Old Dominion Monarchs, Towson Tigers, VCU Rams, William & Mary Tribe, Chicago State Cougars, Houston Christian Huskies, N.J.I.T. Highlanders, North Dakota Fighting Hawks, Texas-RGV Vaqueros, Utah Valley Wolverines, Butler Bulldogs, Cleveland State Vikings, Detroit-Mercy Titans, Green Bay Phoenix, Illinois-Chicago Flames, Loyola (IL) Ramblers, Milwaukee Panthers, Valparaiso Beacons, Wright State Raiders, Youngstown State Penguins, Cal State Bakersfield Roadrunners, Longwood Lancers, Omaha Mavericks, Seattle Redhawks, Brown Bears, Columbia Lions, Cornell Big Red, Dartmouth Big Green, Harvard Crimson, Pennsylvania Quakers, Princeton Tigers, Yale Bulldogs, Canisius Golden Griffins, Fairfield Stags, Iona Gaels, Loyola (MD) Greyhounds, Manhattan Jaspers, Marist Red Foxes, Niagara Purple Eagles, Rider Broncs, Saint Peter's Peacocks, Siena Saints, Akron Zips, Ball State Cardinals, Bowling Green Falcons, Buffalo Bulls, Central Michigan Chippewas, Eastern Michigan Eagles, Kent State Golden Flashes, Miami (OH) RedHawks, Northern Illinois Huskies, Ohio Bobcats, Toledo Rockets, Western Michigan Broncos, Bethune-Cookman Wildcats, Coppin State Eagles, Delaware State Hornets, Florida A&M Rattlers, Hampton Pirates, Howard Bison, Maryland-Eastern Shore Hawks, Morgan State Bears, Norfolk State Spartans, North Carolina A&T Aggies, North Carolina Central Eagles, Savannah State Tigers, South Carolina State Bulldogs, Bradley Braves, Creighton Bluejays, Drake Bulldogs, Evansville Purple Aces, Illinois State Redbirds, Indiana State Sycamores, Missouri State Bears, Northern Iowa Panthers, Southeast Missouri State Redhawks, Southern Illinois Salukis, Wichita State Shockers, Air Force Falcons, Boise State Broncos, Colorado State Rams, New Mexico Lobos, San Diego State Aztecs, TCU Horned Frogs, UNLV Runnin' Rebels, Wyoming Cowboys, Bryant Bulldogs, Central Connecticut State Blue Devils, Fairleigh Dickinson Knights, Long Island Sharks, Monmouth Hawks, Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers, Quinnipiac Bobcats, Robert Morris Colonials, Sacred Heart Pioneers, St. Francis (NY) Terriers, St. Francis (PA) Red Flash, Wagner Seahawks, Austin Peay Governors, Eastern Illinois Panthers, Eastern Kentucky Colonels, Jacksonville State Gamecocks, Morehead State Eagles, Murray State Racers, SIU-Edwardsville Cougars, Tennessee State Tigers, Tennessee Tech Golden Eagles, Tennessee-Martin Skyhawks, Arizona Wildcats, Arizona State Sun Devils, California Golden Bears, Colorado Buffaloes, Oregon Ducks, Oregon State Beavers, Stanford Cardinal, UCLA Bruins, USC Trojans, Utah Utes, Washington Huskies, Washington State Cougars, American University Eagles, Army West Point Black Knights, Bucknell Bison, Colgate Raiders, Holy Cross Crusaders, Lafayette Leopards, Lehigh Mountain Hawks, Navy Midshipmen, Alabama Crimson Tide, Arkansas Razorbacks, Auburn Tigers, Florida Gators, Georgia Bulldogs, Kentucky Wildcats, LSU Tigers, Mississippi State Bulldogs, Ole Miss Rebels, South Carolina Gamecocks, Tennessee Volunteers, Vanderbilt Commodores, Appalachian State Mountaineers, Charleston Cougars, Chattanooga Mocs, The Citadel Bulldogs, Davidson Wildcats, Elon Phoenix, Furman Paladins, Georgia Southern Eagles, Samford Bulldogs, UNC Greensboro Spartans, Western Carolina Catamounts, Wofford Terriers, Central Arkansas Bears, Lamar Cardinals, McNeese State Cowboys, Nicholls State Colonels, Northwestern State Demons, Sam Houston State Bearkats, Southeastern Louisiana Lions, Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks, Texas A&M-CC Islanders, Texas State Bobcats, Texas-Arlington Mavericks, Texas-San Antonio Roadrunners, Fort Wayne Mastodons, IUPUI Jaguars, UMKC Kangaroos, North Dakota State Bison, Oakland Golden Grizzlies, Oral Roberts Golden Eagles, South Dakota Coyotes, South Dakota State Jackrabbits, Southern Utah Thunderbirds, Western Illinois Leathernecks, Alabama A&M Bulldogs, Alabama State Hornets, Alcorn State Braves, Grambling State Tigers, Jackson State Tigers, Mississippi Valley State Delta Devils, Prairie View A&M Panthers, Southern Jaguars, Texas Southern Tigers, Fresno State Bulldogs, Hawaii Rainbow Warriors, Idaho Vandals, Louisiana Tech Bulldogs, Nevada Wolf Pack, New Mexico State Aggies, San Jose State Spartans, Utah State Aggies, Brigham Young Cougars, Gonzaga Bulldogs, Loyola Marymount Lions, Pepperdine Waves, Portland Pilots, Saint Mary's Gaels, San Diego Toreros, San Francisco Dons, Santa Clara Broncos, Atlantic Coast Conference, Big Ten Conference, Big 12 Conference, American Athletic Conference, Missouri Valley Conference, Mountain West Conference, Pacific-12 Conference, Southeastern Conference, Conference USA, Atlantic 10 Conference, West Coast Conference, Horizon League, Western Athletic Conference, Ivy League, Coastal Athletic Association, Ohio Valley Conference, Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference, America East Conference, Atlantic Sun Conference, Big Sky Conference, Big South Conference, Big West Conference, Independents Conference, Great West Conference, Mid-American Conference, Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference, Northeast Conference, Patriot League, Southern Conference, Southland Conference, Southwestern Athletic Conference, The Summit League, Sun Belt Conference, Anaheim Classic, ACC Men's Basketball Tournament, America East Men's Basketball Tournament, Atlantic 10 Men's Basketball Tournament, Atlantic Sun Men's Basketball Tournament, Battle 4 Atlantis, Big 12 Men's Basketball Tournament, American Athletic Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Big Sky Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Big South Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Big Ten Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Big West Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, CAA Men's Basketball Tournament, Cancun Challenge, Cancun Governor's Cup, Hall of Fame Classic, Charleston Classic, Chicago Invitational Challenge, Coaches vs. Cancer Classic, College Basketball Invitational, CollegeInsider.com Tournament, Conference USA Men's Basketball Tournament, Diamond Head Classic, Glenn Wilkes Classic, Great Alaska Shootout, Great West Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Hall of Fame Tip-Off, Horizon League Men's Basketball Tournament, Las Vegas Classic, Las Vegas Invitational, Legends Classic, MAAC Men's Basketball Tournament, Allstate Maui Invitational, Mid-American Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Missouri Valley Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Mountain West Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, NCAA Tournament, NIT Season Tip-Off, NIT Tournament, Northeast Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Ohio Valley Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, ESPN Orlando Invitational, Pacific-12 Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Paradise Jam, Patriot League Men's Basketball Tournament, Puerto Rico Tip-Off, SEC Men's Basketball Tournament, South Padre Island Invitational, Southern Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Southland Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, Sun Belt Men's Basketball Tournament, SWAC Men's Basketball Tournament, The Summit League Men's Basketball Tournament, WAC Men's Basketball Tournament, West Coast Conference Men's Basketball Tournament, NCAA, NBA, NBA NBA Draft, NBA Draft General